Consigning at Cottontails

We accept clothing, baby gear & furniture, toys, and more!  


You receive 40% of the final selling price (50% for any items priced over $50) and can get a check or use as store credit


*Review our contract for more details*



Babies grow

so  fast! Consign your gently used items with us.

Download & Review Our Consignor Contract!

What We Accept

Seasonal Clothing

Clothing is accepted seasonally, like in department stores (Spring starts in Jan, Fall in July, etc).  We accept newborn to size 16/transitions into small juniors/young mens, and maternity. 


Present your items freshly washed, neatly folded with sets together & buttons buttoned.

All items must be free of:

  • Stains

  • Odors

  • Pet hair

  • Holes/tears

  • Signs of wear, etc.  

**We do not accept slippers, onesies, incomplete infant outfits or bargain brands (Circo, Garanimals, etc) or older items/hand-me-downs.**
Baby Equipment,  Toys & Furniture

All items must be: 

  • In excellent condition and cleaned 

  • Have all pieces (including working  batteries)   

  • Fairly current (ideally no more than a couple of years old)

  • Up to date on all safety standards

Age restrictions will vary by item.  Feel free to call with questions. 

**We do not accept opened board games, stuffed animals or decor. 

Certain sets or toys with lots of parts may not be accepted.**

Consignment Options

Up to 30 pieces of clothing

2x a month


You may come in any time we are open. We will look through your items at a later time and will donate anything we cannot accept for sale.

This option may be temporarily suspended as needed.  Check website for status prior to coming in. 

**Please pre-sort and bring in your best, most current items neatly folded.**


Current season: 


For Clothing:

'Drop & Donate' 



Please ask an employee for a contract. First-time clothing consignors have the option to pick up unaccepted items so you get a better feel for what we accept. Please alert an employee if this is your preference. Otherwise, unaccepted items will be donated. 

Baby Gear, Toys & Furniture

Please call or email us to schedule a drop off.  We do not accept walk-ins for these items, but can usually fit customers in within a day or two. 

Feel free to call, email or send a message on Instagram or Facebook.

**Please ensure that items have been cleaned and have all parts (incl. batteries) before scheduling.**


Tinton Falls Plaza (behind Americana Diner)

980 Shrewsbury Ave

Tinton Falls, NJ 07724

Follow Us
HOURS: Open 7 days!
Daily: 10 - 6
Thurs: 10 - 7
Sun: 11 - 4
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Yelp Icon