Consigning at Cottontails

We accept clothing, baby gear & furniture, toys, and more!  


You receive 40% of the final selling price (50% for any items priced over $50) and can get a check or use as store credit


*Review our contract for more details*



Babies grow

so  fast! Consign your gently used items with us.

Download & Review Our Consignor Contract!

What We Accept

Baby Equipment,  Toys & Furniture

All items must be: 

  • In excellent condition and cleaned 

  • Have all pieces (including working  batteries)   

  • Fairly current (ideally no more than a couple of years old)

  • Up to date on all safety standards

Age restrictions will vary by item.  Feel free to call with questions. 

**We do not accept opened board games, stuffed animals or decor. 

Certain sets or toys with lots of parts may not be accepted.**


Clothing is accepted seasonally, like in department stores (Spring starts in Jan, Fall in July, etc).  We accept newborn to size 16/transitions into small juniors/young mens, and maternity. 


Present your items freshly washed, neatly folded with sets together & buttons buttoned.


Current items only; no bargain brands, please.

All items must be free of:

  • Stains

  • Odors

  • Pet hair

  • Holes/tears

  • Signs of wear, etc.  

**We do not accept slippers, onesies, incomplete infant outfits or bargain brands (Circo, Garanimals, etc) or older items/hand-me-downs.**

Consignment Options


For Clothing:

'Drop & Donate' 

Up to 30 pieces of clothing

2x a month


You may come in any time we are open. We will look through your items at a later time and will donate anything we cannot accept for sale.

This option may be temporarily suspended as needed.  Check website for status prior to coming in. 

**Please pre-sort and bring in your best, most current items neatly folded.**

Baby Gear, Toys & Furniture

Please call or email us to schedule a drop off.  We do not accept walk-ins for these items, but can usually fit customers in within a day or two. 

Feel free to call, email or send a message on Instagram or Facebook.

**Please ensure that items have been cleaned and have all parts (incl. batteries) before scheduling.**

Current season: 



Please ask an employee for a contract. First-time clothing consignors have the option to pick up unaccepted items so you get a better feel for what we accept. Please alert an employee if this is your preference. Otherwise, unaccepted items will be donated. 

First time consingors please read below.

Due to COVID-19, both our Tues/Thurs "Walk-in & Wait" option and the Online Scheduled appointmets are suspended for the rest of this year.


Tinton Falls Plaza (behind Americana Diner)

980 Shrewsbury Ave

Tinton Falls, NJ 07724

Follow Us
HOURS: Open 7 days!
Daily: 10 - 6
Thurs: 10 - 7
Sun: 11 - 4
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Yelp Icon