Tinton Falls Plaza (behind Americana Diner)

980 Shrewsbury Ave

Tinton Falls, NJ 07724

Follow Us
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Yelp Icon
Daily 10am – 6pm
Thursday 10am – 7pm
Sunday 11am – 4pm


Consigning at Cottontails

We accept clothing, baby gear & furniture, toys, and more!  


You receive 40% of the final selling price (50% for any items priced over $50) and can get a check or use as store credit


*Review our contract for more details*



Babies grow

so  fast! Consign your gently used items with us.


Clothing is accepted seasonally.

 Newborn to small teen sizes

• Current styles only

(Past 2-3 years)

• No hand-me-downs

• Neatly folded, sets together

**We do have clothing limits (depends on which option you're doing: see below) so please pre-sort and bring us your best!  This will ensure you get more items accepted. 




We accept a variety of brands, from Carters, Gap, Gymboree, to Crew Cuts, Ralph Lauren & boutique names.  


We avoid the "mart" brands such as those sold at Kmart & Walmart and are very selective on brands like Old Navy, Children's Place, Forever21, etc.

**Items must be be free of

stains, holes,

tears, odors, pet hair, etc. and show only minimal signs of wear.**



Baby Equipment

Baby gear & furniture need to be cleaned, have all pieces, working batteries, and must not be recalled.  Items should be assembled once here (except cribs).  


These items must be fairly current, but age restrictions vary by item. Contact us for details. 



Toys need to be clean, have all pieces & working batteries.  

We do not accept open board games, generic stuffed animals, TV-plug in toys, or puzzles with lots of pieces. Certain sets and toys with lots of parts may not be accepted. 

Download & Review Our Consignor Contract!

Scheduling Options


Schedule Online

For primarily clothing


The best option if you have a lot of clothing. You can bring in up to 50 pieces per appointment (min. of 25).  You may also bring in up to 15 small toy or misc. items.


Baby gear may also be brought in during your appointment, but please call ahead to confirm specific items. 


Clothing Walk-Ins

Under 20 pieces of clothing

during set hours

*This option will be suspended as needed, so always check here before coming in.*

During walk-in hours only

(no appnt needed):

  • Tues & Thursdays only

  • Between 11-3pm

  • Max of 20 pieces

( One walk-in every other week per

consignor, please)

Gear & Toys

Just call us in advance

Non-clothing items such as

larger baby gear and toys can be

scheduled simply by calling us

ahead of time.   We can usually

fit you in within a few days. 


Perfect for clearing out

the big stuff fast! 

Our online winter schedule is fully booked. 

Resume Tuesday 11/19

Give us a call (or email) to schedule. We can usually fit you in within a few days for these.